The field teams for Eawag's 4S project are now all trained and ready to go. The past couple of weeks have been a lot of site visits to wastewater treatment plants at schools, office buildings, and factories and we've seen the whole range of successful and catastrophically failed. I’ve been working to select communities that have
community-based sanitation systems (meaning these systems are intended to have
some level of community participation and community-based management after they’re
constructed, as opposed to a hired outside operator or a commercial application)
to study for my research. That’s the struggle of the century. I’ve read more
about sanitation in India than anywhere else, but somehow it’s incredibly
challenging to encounter the diversity of community-based sanitation systems
practically here that I’m seeking. There is almost no organized information or
available documentation on existing projects, especially if they are
community-based. If we combine this with communities that have been
over-studied and are uninterested in further interviewing, and with
organizations that are almost paralyzed with inefficiency and being overworked,
and add language barriers and traffic and power outages, then we arrive where I’m
presently sitting, in a state of frustration and patience-building. I knew
going into this that the human aspect of my research would absolutely dictate
the timeline and that even my most ambitious efforts to arrange the work I’m
striving to accomplish may fall short of the ideal, but that has been a
difficult adjustment regardless. Anyway, Lukas and I have co-selected about
thirty sanitation systems that are relevant to the 4S project and my own
research and I’m hoping we will have site visits arranged for those over the
next three weeks. There is also a community-based system right next to our
office that I may be able to use as an opportunity to pilot my interviews and
make adjustments before I further select additional communities. I also got
thirteen mosquito bites while writing that paragraph, and I’m wearing bug spray.
It’s almost like I’m back in Panama.
So recently, I’ve been trying to learn as much as I can
about the different regulations, organizations, and cultural dimensions that
govern the community-based and small-scale sanitation sector in India. Sometimes,
while feeling like a sponge, I wonder how it’s possible for people to not like
learning (and laugh at myself for ever seriously considering not going to grad
school). It's the actual most complex issue that I think I have ever encountered. You have a government that's trying to end open defecation by 2019 and create more regulations so that more of the waste is treated and transition the lowest caste out of street-sweeping, waste picking, and toilet cleaning as their only employment. Then you have a society that perpetuates the castes by being unwilling to acknowledge them or entertain the thoughts of paying someone more to do the same undesirable job. Then you also have a level of corruption that permeates every societal strata, often meaning that regulations are only created to provide more levels at which officials can accept bribes. It's cyclical and it sometimes feels quite hopeless until you meet some of the people that are working within the organizations I've encountered. There are people like Pradeep who know seven or eight languages and try to buck the system at every opportunity. There are people like Geeta who are well-spoken, forceful women whose intellect, creativity, and motivation may very well change the entire system. Maybe they are the ones who will actually make a difference.
One of the most characteristic things here is that nearly every issue
is surrounded by lots of talk, but very few witness action. I watched a talk from TEDxBangalore that keeps
surfacing in my mind as one of the best ways to describe India (or maybe just people as a whole). The anonymous
speaker is presenting the Ugly Indian movement, where groups of anonymous
citizens band together to clean up particularly ugly spaces within the city,
with the hopes that once something becomes beautiful, it stays beautiful since
no one is willing to be the one to turn it back into a trash dump. Anyway, one
of the most impactful things the speaker says is that in India, nothing ever
changes because no one ever does anything and expects the responsibility to be
someone else’s job. To run the risk of generalizing, Indians are so hospitable,
but when you put them in a car, an ‘everyone for themselves’ mentality comes
out. Traffic stays horrifically awful, because no one follows the rules because
no one else is and no one is willing to make a change. Solid waste piles up on
the street because someone else threw it there first and I’m not going to clean
up my neighbor’s mess. The Ugly Indian movement is so revolutionary because he
emphasizes the obligation to get out and do something instead of complaining
and expecting someone else to make the change.
Last week, I got to sit in on a meeting with the Karnataka
State Pollution Control Board chairman and former chairman. This is like
meeting with the chairman of the California State Water Resources Control Board
(except a slightly more dysfunctional version of the board). CDD was presenting
two major requests to the chairman: that the KSPCB would develop an operator
certification process and system to formally recognize operator training
programs; and that they would develop regulations for fecal sludge treatment
plants. The latter of these means it would pave the way for the construction of
more (there are extremely limited numbers in Karnataka now, possibly only one)
plants that can treat the fecal sludge that is pumped out of septic tanks, pit
latrines, and other treatment modules. It was so interesting (not that anything
in India so far hasn’t been ‘so interesting’) to be a fly on the wall for this
one. The red carpet was rolled out, and coffee and pastries were served for
this fifteen minute presentation that was filled with formality and a lot of
clapping, but I couldn’t help but wonder if this is just another example of
talk without action. It definitely was one large moment of ‘how did I get here?’
I had a fascinating conversation with three of the CDD field
interns about arranged marriages and dowries in India. At least in the south,
they all agreed that Kerala has the best practices, as the man’s family does
not ask for dowries and the negotiations are more focused on the woman’s
education levels and family status. But even in some of the more ‘progressive’
parts of the conversation, never once was the man’s worth, qualities, or
character mentioned and the girls seemed to accept that. In another
conversation with some of the older women who work at CDD (and by older I mean
age 30-40 who look still 15), I found out that two of them have chosen not to
get married because they are so fed up with the process and the priority that
so much of Indian culture places on marriage. I also had a wonderful cab driver
this week who is Muslim and was so interested to hear about religious conflict
in the U.S. and was more than willing to tell me his experience as a Muslim in
a predominantly Hindu country. It seems like the southern part of India is much
more open, accepting, and peaceful to live (in general) than the north, likely
due in part to the fact that they are much farther away from their Muslim
neighbors (Pakistan, Bangladesh). I’ve realized how unique it is to have the
opportunity to discuss things like politics and religion and arranged marriage
so openly here. Maybe it’s because I’ve mastered the Indian head bob so my
listening skills are now impeccable.

What else is important in my life?
This cup of chai that costs 2 cents and is amazing. |
The latest arrival in my rotating roommate saga is an old
Swedish man named Jan-Olof. He arrived at 3:30 am without a key, so I spent
about ten minutes debating how dumb of an idea it would be to open the door in
the middle of the night to whoever had rung the bell a hundred times. Ended up
being a safe decision, although his bottle of port wine had broken and spilled
all over my bare feet. He’s the co-owner and mastermind of the EcoHouse and
comes about four times a year to tinker around and make adjustments. Apparently,
the house is only a year old which makes some of the unfinished pieces make a
lot more sense. He’s installing a bathroom in the downstairs bedroom (my room)
which maybe will mean that I don’t have to shower with an army of cockroaches,
or the army might move downstairs. All kinds of important people have come by
to see the house (architects, rich men, etc.) so Jan-Olof is trying to make it
even more presentable in such a way that inspires its replication all over the
world. It’s never not going to be strange though to live here in this house
that overlooks an open defecation field.
I’m also really starting to understand why so many people
here are ‘veg’ (as opposed to ‘non-veg’). There are only so many times that you
can watch a cow eat trash and still want to eat said cow. But then again, if my
diet was entirely mango I think I would turn orange, shrivel, and die.
I’ve already been invited to a wedding. Unfortunately, the
invitation is all in either Hindi or Kannada so all I can read is the date. An
enthusiastic man brought 150 invitations to the office and handed them out to
everyone, I guess allowing him to bandage my bleeding knee was sufficient
contact to be invited.
I got sick for the first time here, but I think it was more
acid reflux than food poisoning or India. But you know you’re a nerd when you
accidentally throw up into the urine diversion part of the toilet and then
google vomit and urine nutrients to compare and make sure you didn’t ruin the
whole fertilizer system.
For the days that I go to the office, when I leave I engage
in ten minutes of physical activity (ten is about the limit before you run the
risk of passing out or just generally horrifying the public with how much you
are capable of sweating) while I wait for my pickup. The girls from the little
slum settlement right across the street usually play badminton (learned right
now that word isn’t spelled like the glove variant) and have all learned my
name and will literally yell the moment they see me leaving the office to have
me come play. I’m actually extremely good at the version where we used ping
pong paddles and the birdie, and am unbelievably awful at the real version with
a badminton paddle (paddle is probably the wrong word but I’m too focused on my
athleticism to care). It’s actually really fun until a gigantic herd of goats
goes plowing through the street and you feel like you’re going to be knocked
into the sewer and never recover.
![]() |
![]() |
An embarrassingly large number of people have asked me if I’ve
found an Indian boyfriend yet so I thought I’d give a global update and say
that while I have not, I have been offered (begged, really) to take someone’s
son home with me to the U.S.. The man used the same breath to tell me that
marriage to an American is ‘very favorable’ and my dowry could be his son’s
visa. Quite flattering, really. I will be seeing this family quite a lot, as
they are my second favorite restaurant in my neighborhood and have offered me
both free delivery and free ‘leg soup’ while I’m here. I never did get an
answer to what kind of leg the soup is from.
A dog followed me home from the store this week too. It was
terrible. Most of the dogs thus far have had a great ‘you don’t touch me, I don’t
touch you’ mentality that I’m totally on board with. Except this one tiny,
annoying dog. I think he wanted a share of my weekly shipment of mangoes and
basically nipped at my heels for 2 kilometers. I think I crossed the street
like eight additional times to avoid this dog and by the end I probably was
running and maybe even crying and all of my neighbors were laughing at me. The
scariest encounter I’ve had so far in India.
In other news, I discovered that the many signs that warn
you of ‘leopard crossings’ aren’t a joke and are a real thing and most of my
friends have ‘frequently’ seen leopards eating trash on the outskirts of the
city. So I guess neighborhood dogs aren’t the only terror to be afraid of here.
Also, here are some of my friends:
That’s all for now. Going to go back to sitting in shock that I’ve been here for almost an entire month already.
No comments:
Post a Comment